Frank Miller, writer
Dave Gibbons, artist
(1) Earlier this year there was a tremendous controversy within the sci-fi blogging community that started with a post by a noted white sci-fi writer about writing "the other," i.e., someone that does not look like you or share your life experiences. It led to a great conversation amongst bloggers and other writers - many of color, some not - about their experiences, frustrations, and expectations with reading and writing minority characters in sci-fi. Dubbed "
RaceFail," it provided an opportunity for the ongoing dialogue about race in science fiction to be taken to the next level. It remains to be seen where the discussion will lead to.
One of the salient points brought up in the back-and-forth conversation is that it is not enough to introduce a minority character in a story and write him or her no differently from the white ones. Cultural aspects and experiences should also factor into the minority character's personality if a minority reader is to identify with and invest in him or her.
Frank Miller, the controversial comics creator turned filmmaker, is not known for his portrayals of minorities in his work, but in at least one case he hit it out of the ballpark: Martha Washington, the protagonist of the graphic novel
Give Me Liberty (and its sequels). Set in what was the future at the time it came out (the bulk of the narrative takes place over three years beginning in 2010... so I guess that's still the future after all!), what Martha is - a black woman - factors into how she's treated by others, but ultimately who she is matters more, because it gives her the strength to survive and thrive in a world that has stacked the odds against her from day one.
Born in a Chicago slum literally walled off from the rest of the world, declared mentally insane and locked up in an asylum as an adolescent, Martha sees the U.S. military, the PAX Peace Force, as her ticket out of poverty. She quickly ascends the ranks, but a privileged senior officer looking to profit from war sees her as a threat. When he takes advantage of a government fallen to pieces, it's up to Martha (with help from some unlikely friends) to stop him.
Miller sets
Liberty in a society that, like his groundbreaking comic
The Dark Knight Returns, is decadent and corrupt from the top down. The president has rewritten the constitution, allowing him to stay in office for more than two terms. The economy is heavily invested in military intervention at home and abroad, at the expense of the poor and the environment, and as a result, America is fractured into a number of territories seeking autonomy. Throughout the book,
Watchmen-like excerpts from magazines and television reports provide the exposition needed to further flesh out this world.
Liberty is full of bizarre and at times over-the-top characters and imagery that serve to underscore the absurdity of war and the people who wage it (one example among many: a giant robot of a fast-food mascot attacking PAX troops in the Amazon jungle).
Amidst all of this comes Martha who, although she is born into a segregated community specifically designed to keep her and everyone like her (read: blacks) in, she finds a way out (albeit unintentionally), and once she joins PAX , she's smart enough to rise in the ranks and eventually improve the quality of life for her family and neighbors. Miller's trademark pseudo-noir, angst-ridden narration is on display here, along with his propensity for repetition ("Nobody's laughing at the Aryan Thrust. Not now. Pointing your own cannon right down your throats. Right down your throats. So nobody's laughing"). Like
Dark Knight though, it all feels like an integral part of the absurd nature of this world, where blonde muscular clones, masochistic doctors, Indian freedom fighters and gay Nazi terrorists point giant phallic laser cannons at each other and engage in political assassinations.
Martha, at times, seems aware of the craziness but it doesn't keep her from doing her duty, not even when Moretti, her commanding officer, gets in her way. Moretti, a rich white male looking out only for himself, manipulates the system and maneuvers himself into a position of power and influence, while Martha must fight for everything she earns. The contrasts between the two speak directly to the black experience in America throughout history, in which a white person usually can get advantages a black person can't, regardless of whether they're earned or not. In this instance, Martha's strength of character, her resiliency, and her intelligence prove to be more than equal compensation.
Dave Gibbons is one of the all-time great comics illustrators. Here, as with his work on
Watchmen, his layouts are clean and sharp, his figures have weight, variety and emotion, and his black people actually look like black people, not whites colored brown. The splash page in the first chapter where Martha defiantly wipes away her tears is a knockout and speaks volumes about who she is.
Martha Washington could've been a white heroine, but in choosing to make her black, Miller and Gibbons dug a little deeper and explored the consequences of being black in a world like this - and then they built her personality around that. The result is an utterly unforgettable character and an expertly crafted tale.
--------------------------
Dark Horse, 216 pp., color, $16
ISBN-10: 0440504465
ISBN-13: 978-0440504467
AMAZON LINK TO BUYAlso:Martha Washington entry @ Wikipedia